Talk:Kirara Hoshi

There's too little evidence as to what gender Kirara is to have them listed as a trans man, they could very well also be a trans woman since Megumi seems to remember them having been presenting as male before with him being confused about them going by a feminine name now. They could also be a feminine cis boy or non binary but since all we're going off for their gender is this unclear line (which could also be Panda misgendering them if they are a trans woman) we will have to wait til the next few chapters to know for sure. - Written by User:GaaraOfTheSandwich

Kirara being transgender in general is an assumption and too early to judge. No pronouns were used for them and dialogue was clearly written to refer to them as a boy. Kirara can be androgynous without being trans. This is a very touchy subject I would like to avoid altogether. The gender is staying male until further notice. Anything beyond that is fan head-canon and a wiki operates based on the information the author gives us. --Mako3 14:34, 10 August 2021 (UTC)

I agree. As far as I know, Megumi hadn't ever heard of Kirara before any of this and Panda just randomly mentioned her whilst they were talking about Hakari, so the way I interpreted it was that Megumi thought that Kirara was Hakari's "born" name or something, and asked for clarification on whether or not Hakari was a male because Kirara is a pretty feminine sounding name (which is weird coming from Megumi of all people). If you reread the panel, Megumi says "Kirara...? I thought the other 3rd year student was a man right?" and he can only be talking about Hakari here because Kirara isn't a Jujutsu High student, nor has she ever once been mentioned by any of the Jujutsu High staff or anything so I don't think she was ever affiliated with them. It also doesn't really make sense for Megumi and Panda to have known that Kirara would have been male at one point if she was trans. - Written by User:ThisaintThat

The idea they’re talking about Hakari is completely false and you should reread the last two chapters. Panda mentions Kirara’s technique. Megumi goes “Kirara” because that’s a feminine sounding name but Panda reaffirms that the other third year their talking about is a boy. They're very obviously not talking about Hakari and you're reading into it far too heavily. Kirara is a jujutsu student and if you don't know that you haven't been paying close attention. The chapter before the new release, in Kirara’s introduction text, it literally has Jujutsu High under their name. they've also talked about Kirara being another third year more than once. Kirara is obviously affiliated with the school and the dialogue between Panda and Megumi is very clearly referring to them. --Mako3 14:34, 10 August 2021 (UTC)